Wednesday, April 11, 2012

Downshifting vs. Voluntary Simplicity

Getting into the real research details of my project, I'm learning that there are two designations (at least) when it comes to changing spending habits. There are "downshifters" and "new frugality" or "voluntary simplicity". It's not too hard to learn the differences. Downshifting is probably what I'm doing, although the demographics for this category tend to skew older. Downshifter philosophy tends to lean towards having a more enriching life, having more time to spend with loved ones, and finding a budget and lifestyle that is more in tune with those values. Voluntary Simplicity is almost spartan living. Truly minimizing possessions, to the point of hardly owning anything. While a downshifter might drive an older car, someone following Voluntary Simplicity would not own a car at all, relying on walking, biking, and public transportation as needed.

I like the concept of Voluntary Simplicity. There is a communal feeling to the lifestyle that I appreciate, but in a lot of ways, it does separate people from their old friends. A new community can develop, but it's hard to have an average social life if you have no car and don't pay for dinners out or movies. This is the point where you would need to seek out Simple Living peers, because they are the only ones who would truly support and understand what you are doing. For this reason, Downshifting appeals to me more. I can remain in my community and easily maintain friendships and connections. I feel like I can make more choices, rather than rejecting everything I have come to know in my life.

There is a lot of appeal to the Voluntary Simplicity movement, but in my current living situation, it would be impossible.

No comments:

Post a Comment